Effectiveness of urban wastewater treatment policies in

1,44
MB selected countries: an EEA pilot study

56
stron

5591
ID European Environment Agency

2005
rok

Contents

Acknowledgements . 4

Executive summary . 5

1. Setting the scene: the EEA and policy effectiveness evaluations 8

1.1 European clean water policies .8

1.2 Meeting information demands .8

1.3 EEA policy effectiveness evaluations 9

1.4 The approach of this study .9

2. Methodological considerations . 11

2.1 Introduction . 11

2.2 Policy in focus 11

2.3 Effects: outputs of urban wastewater treatment policy . 12

2.4 Effectiveness: outcomes of urban wastewater treatment policy . 13

2.5 Explaining differences 15

2.6 Cost-effectiveness 17

3. Denmark 18

3.1 Water quality situation 18

3.2 Water quality policy objectives 18

3.3 Institutional context 18

3.4 Policy Instruments 19

3.5 Observations on effectiveness 19

4. France 20

4.1 Water quality situation 20

4.2 Water quality policy objectives 20

4.3 Institutional context 21

4.4 Policy instruments 21

4.5 Observations on effectiveness 22

5. The Netherlands 23

5.1 Water quality situation 23

5.2 Water quality policy objectives 23

5.3 Institutional context 24

5.4 Policy instruments 24

5.5 Observations on effectiveness 25

6. Spain . 26

6.1 Water quality situation 26

6.2 Water quality policy objectives 26

6.3 Institutional context 27

6.4 Policy instruments 27

6.5 Observations on effectiveness 28

7. Estonia . 29

7.1 Water quality situation 29

7.2 Water quality policy objectives 29

7.3 Institutional context 30

7.4 Policy instruments 30

7.5 Observations on effectiveness 31

8. Poland . 32

8.1 Water quality situation 32

8.2 Water quality policy objectives 32

8.3 Institutional context 33

8.4 Policy instruments 33

8.5 Observations on effectiveness 34

9. Comparative analysis . 35

9.1 Introduction . 35

9.2 Effects 35

9.3 Effectiveness 38

9.4 Cost-effectiveness 41

10. Conclusions . 46

References .. 48

Annex Some options for further work related to the effectiveness of urban wastewater treatment

policies 51